There’s a surprising lack of real evidence comparing scripture-based parenting guides to secular or other values-based resources, especially in mixed-faith or non-religious homes. Most of what’s out there is anecdotal or framed to “preach to the choir.” I’ve mostly seen positive effects on family cohesion and emotional vocabulary-provided the parents use scripture to spark honest, age-appropriate conversations, rather than enforce moral absolutes. For non-religious or multi-faith settings, resources like “Parenting Beyond Belief” offer a more inclusive framework rooted in empathy and critical thinking, but they rarely reference scripture. Honestly, evidence points to modeling compassionate behavior and maintaining open dialogues as more important than the text you quote. Has anyone come across a rigorous, side-by-side study? If so, I’d be very interested in the methodology.
